Get in touch

In Auckland, and need a quote? Get in touch today.

Contact Us →

Gasfitting Services Auckland

Need gas heating installed or gas appliances fitted in Auckland? Our certified gas fitters handle all your heating and gas installation needs safely.

Get in touch

In Auckland, and need a quote? Get in touch today.

Contact Us →

Hot Water Cylinder Element and Thermostat Problems: Signs and Fixes

TL;DR

If your hot water is only lukewarm, runs out faster than it used to or takes a long time to heat, a worn element or a faulty thermostat inside an electric cylinder is a common cause. These parts can often be replaced without replacing the whole cylinder. A plumber can work out which part has failed. Do not open electrical covers yourself.

Key Takeaways

  • The element heats the water and the thermostat controls the temperature, so either one failing can leave you with poor hot water.
  • Lukewarm water, hot water that runs out quickly and a cylinder that never seems to finish heating are the usual signs.
  • A failed element or thermostat is often a part replacement, not a new cylinder.
  • Water leaking from the cylinder body is a different problem and usually means replacement.
  • Never remove electrical covers or keep resetting a switch that trips. Call a plumber.

A hot water cylinder element or thermostat that has worn out is one of the most common reasons an electric cylinder stops heating properly. The cylinder still looks fine, the switch is on, and yet the shower never gets hot. It is frustrating, but it is often a fixable fault.

In this post, you’ll learn what these two parts do, the signs that one of them is failing and how a plumber decides between a repair and a new cylinder.

What the element and thermostat do

An electric storage cylinder heats water with one or two elements, which work like the element in a kettle. A thermostat sits alongside and switches the element on and off so the water stays at the temperature it is set to. Both parts work hard every day, and over the years they wear.

Because they work as a pair, a fault in one can look like a fault in the other. An element that has burnt out cannot heat the water at all. A thermostat that has failed can stop the element switching on, or leave it on when it should not be. That is why a proper test matters.

Signs the element or thermostat is failing

Watch for water that is lukewarm when it used to be hot, hot water that runs out far faster than it used to, and a cylinder that takes much longer than usual to recover after a big use. Some cylinders also make odd noises as the parts struggle, and some trip the switch at the switchboard as soon as they are turned on.

If the water is hot at first and then goes cold quickly, one element may have failed while the other still works. If there is no hot water at all, the element, the thermostat or the power supply could all be the cause. Our guide to what to check when you have no hot water covers the first steps.

Element, thermostat or something else?

The same symptoms can come from a few different faults, which is why guessing is a poor plan. A tripped circuit, a fault in the wiring or switchboard, a problem with the mixing valve or a leak can all look like a failed element. A plumber can test the parts in a sensible order and tell you what they find.

Some things should stay with the professionals. Do not take off electrical covers, and do not keep resetting a switch that trips, because a trip means there is a fault. If the fault turns out to be in the wiring rather than the cylinder, you will need an electrician, and we will tell you so.

If you can see water around the cylinder, treat it as a leak instead. Switch off the power, close the cold water valve to the cylinder if you can reach it safely, and read our guide on what to do if your hot water cylinder is leaking.

Replace the part or the whole cylinder?

When the cylinder body is sound, replacing a failed element or thermostat can bring the hot water back without the cost of a new cylinder. When the cylinder has other problems, the answer changes. A cylinder that leaks from the body, has needed repeated repairs or is clearly near the end of its life is usually better replaced than repaired again.

Age is part of the picture, but only part. We will look at the cylinder, show you what we found and explain your options in plain English before any work starts. If you want to know more about lifespan, see how long a hot water cylinder lasts and our hot water cylinders page, which covers repairs and replacements.

What to tell your plumber

Tell us when the hot water started to fail and what it is doing: lukewarm, running out fast, or no hot water at all. Mention whether the switch has tripped, whether you have heard any noises and whether you have seen any water around the cylinder. If you can, send a photo of the cylinder label. It usually shows the size and model, which helps us arrive with the right parts.

Call Grace Plumbing

We look after homes in Remuera, Mount Wellington, Ellerslie and Mission Bay. Call 09 525 5733 and tell us what your hot water is doing, or get in touch through the website. Emergency repairs are part of what we do within our business hours, Monday to Friday, 7:30am to 4:30pm. Residential work is backed by the $20,000 Master Plumbers Guarantee. See the areas we serve and our wider plumbing services.

Grace Plumbing - Plumbing Solutions and Services

Quick links

Based on 500+ Reviews

☆☆☆☆☆ (4.9/5)

★★★★★
The team at Grace were flexible and were able to slot in my job at ...
Read More
Kevin Sherlock
★★★★★
The team at Grace were flexible and were able to slot in my job at short notice. Great communication throughout
★★★★★
Awesome experience with the team at Grace Plumbing from start to finish. Great communication
Tommy
★★★★★
Awesome experience with the team at Grace Plumbing from start to finish. Great communication
★★★★★
Ryan carried out the work and was friendly, efficient, and highly professional.
Taki Smart
★★★★★
Ryan carried out the work and was friendly, efficient, and highly professional.
★★★★★
The customer services person on the phone was fantastic - very helpful and understanding.
Mark Warden
★★★★★
The customer services person on the phone was fantastic - very helpful and understanding.
Secret Link