Get in touch

In Auckland, and need a quote? Get in touch today.

Contact Us →

Gasfitting Services Auckland

Need gas heating installed or gas appliances fitted in Auckland? Our certified gas fitters handle all your heating and gas installation needs safely.

Get in touch

In Auckland, and need a quote? Get in touch today.

Contact Us →

Toilet Repair or Replacement: How to Know Which One You Need

TL;DR

Most toilet problems, such as a constantly running cistern or a weak flush, come from a worn part and can be repaired. Think about replacing the toilet if the pan or cistern is cracked, it rocks on the floor, or you have needed repeated repairs.

Key Takeaways

  • A toilet that runs on or refills often needs a new valve or seal, not a new toilet.
  • A weak or incomplete flush is often a part inside the cistern.
  • A cracked pan or cistern needs replacing.
  • A toilet that rocks or leaks at the base should be checked, since water may be getting under it.
  • If the repairs keep coming back, replacing the toilet can be better value.

Deciding on toilet repair or replacement starts with what the toilet is doing. A toilet that runs on, leaks or flushes poorly is annoying, and the water bill can creep up without you noticing. The good news is that many toilet problems are small parts that wear out, and a repair can be quick.

In this post, you’ll learn which problems are usually repairs, which usually mean a replacement and when to call a plumber.

Problems that are usually repairs

Most of the working parts live inside the cistern, and they wear out over time. If the toilet keeps running after you flush, or refills every so often on its own, the cause is often a worn valve or seal. If the flush is weak or the handle feels loose, the flush mechanism may need adjusting or replacing. If water drips from a connection at the back or underneath, a fitting or washer may need replacing.

These are common jobs, and replacing the part is usually enough. A plumber can usually tell what is wrong quickly, and you keep the toilet you already have.

Problems that usually mean replacing the toilet

Some problems are about the toilet itself, not a part inside it. A crack in the pan or the cistern cannot be repaired in a way we would trust, and a cracked toilet can leak. A toilet that rocks on the floor, or that leaks around its base, needs checking. Water can get under it and into the floor, so do not leave this one.

Also think about replacing the toilet if it has needed repeated repairs, if parts are hard to find for an older model, or if you are renovating the bathroom and want something newer. Many newer toilets are designed to use less water, which is worth asking about when you compare options.

Why not to put it off

A running toilet can waste a lot of water without making much noise, and a slow leak at the base can damage the floor over time. Putting it off usually makes the repair bigger. A cracked cistern is likely to get worse, not better. It is better to get a toilet checked while the problem is still small.

What to do while you wait

If the toilet is leaking, turn off the small isolation valve on the water pipe behind or beside the toilet. Turn it clockwise, gently. This stops the water to the cistern, and you can still flush with a bucket in the meantime. If the valve will not turn, leave it and call a plumber rather than forcing it.

If you see water around the base, mop it up so it does not soak into the floor, and tell us when you call.

A simple test for a hidden leak

If your toilet seems to refill by itself, you can check whether water is slipping from the cistern into the bowl. Put a few drops of food colouring in the cistern, leave it for a while without flushing and look in the bowl. If the colour shows up in the bowl, the seal is leaking, and a repair should fix it. It is a small job that can save a lot of wasted water.

What to tell your plumber

Tell us what the toilet is doing, how long it has been doing it and whether there is water on the floor. Let us know how old the toilet is if you know, and whether you plan to renovate the bathroom. A photo of the toilet and the cistern lid helps us bring the right parts.

Call Grace Plumbing

We repair and replace toilets for homeowners in Remuera, Mission Bay, Mount Wellington and Ellerslie. See our toilet repairs and installation page for more, or browse our plumbing services. Call 09 525 5733 or get in touch through the website and tell us what the toilet is doing. Grace Plumbing is open Monday to Friday, 7:30am to 4:30pm. Residential work is backed by the $20,000 Master Plumbers Guarantee. See the areas we serve.

Related reading

Grace Plumbing - Plumbing Solutions and Services

Quick links

Based on 500+ Reviews

☆☆☆☆☆ (4.9/5)

★★★★★
The team at Grace were flexible and were able to slot in my job at ...
Read More
Kevin Sherlock
★★★★★
The team at Grace were flexible and were able to slot in my job at short notice. Great communication throughout
★★★★★
Awesome experience with the team at Grace Plumbing from start to finish. Great communication
Tommy
★★★★★
Awesome experience with the team at Grace Plumbing from start to finish. Great communication
★★★★★
Ryan carried out the work and was friendly, efficient, and highly professional.
Taki Smart
★★★★★
Ryan carried out the work and was friendly, efficient, and highly professional.
★★★★★
The customer services person on the phone was fantastic - very helpful and understanding.
Mark Warden
★★★★★
The customer services person on the phone was fantastic - very helpful and understanding.
Secret Link